Local SEO Case Study: 614 Beauty in Columbus Ohio

This local SEO case study shows how we partnered with 614 Beauty to transform their digital presence, which was in serious trouble. Their previous SEO provider had failed to deliver meaningful results and had also mishandled a full website redesign, leaving significant technical and structural issues behind.

After thoroughly analyzing their website and online presence, we discovered the problems ran deep. But rather than trying to fix everything at once (which would have been expensive and overwhelming), we created a strategic plan that would deliver results quickly while building toward long-term success.

We designed three phases over nine months, each building on the previous one:

  • Foundation First – Fix the broken website so Google could actually find and understand it
  • Strategic Surge – Optimize each page so it shows up when customers search for beauty services
  • Compounding Success – Create valuable content that establishes 614 Beauty as the go-to expert

The results speak for themselves: in just nine months, the number of times 614 Beauty appeared in search results increased by 3.6x, and website clicks grew dramatically, as shown in Figure 1.

Foundation First: 43% Growth from Technical Rebuild

Why we started here: Think of your website like a storefront. If the foundation is cracked, the doors don't open properly, and the signs are unreadable, it doesn't matter how great your products are—customers can't find you or get inside. That was 614 Beauty's website before we stepped in.

Google's search robots were trying to explore the site but kept running into problems. Pages loaded too slowly (customers hate waiting), the site structure was confusing (even for Google), and critical pages weren't even being found by search engines. It's like having a beautiful salon that's impossible to locate because the address doesn't exist in GPS systems.

What we did: We rebuilt the website's foundation from the ground up. We made pages load lightning-fast, organized the site structure so both customers and Google could easily navigate it, and streamlined the code so every important page could be found and understood by search engines.

Why this had to come first: You can't build a house on a broken foundation. Without fixing these fundamental issues, any other marketing efforts would be like putting a fresh coat of paint on a crumbling wall—it might look better temporarily, but it won't last or deliver real results.

The impact was immediate: Search appearances increased 43% in just three months, as shown in Figure 2. More importantly, this gave 614 Beauty a strong base to build on—a turning point in what would later become a compelling local SEO case study of serious growth.

Local SEO case study for 614 Beauty with a graph showing the growth of clicks and impressions for each of the 3 quarters.

Strategic Surge: 130% Growth Through On-Page Mastery

Why this came second: With the technical foundation solid, we could now focus on helping Google better understand what each existing page was actually about. Think of this like adding clear, professional signs to each room in your salon—customers (and Google) can instantly tell which room is for haircuts, which is for facials, and what services you offer.

What we did: We went through every existing page on the website and made Google's job easier. We rewrote page titles to be clearer and more descriptive, improved the brief descriptions that appear in search results, organized content with proper headings, and simplified messy web addresses. We also added descriptions to images so Google understood what they showed, optimized image file sizes for faster loading, and created better connections between related pages on the site.

This wasn't about changing what 614 Beauty offered or creating new content—it was about taking their existing services and presenting them in a way that Google could easily understand and categorize.

Why the sequence mattered: This optimization only works if you have that solid technical foundation we built in phase one. It's like having clear, professional signage, but it's useless if the building itself is hard to find or the doors don't work properly.

The results were dramatic: Search appearances grew 130% in just 6 months. We had more than doubled how often 614 Beauty showed up when customers searched for beauty services.

For 614 Beauty, this wasn’t just a jump in numbers—it meant showing up more than twice as often for the right people at the right time. It's therefore a great real-world local SEO example of how incremental changes, when sequenced correctly, can create outsized results.

Compounding Success: Content-Driven Long-Term Growth

Why this came last: The first two phases got 614 Beauty's existing content showing up in searches and bringing in customers. But phase three is about building lasting dominance in the market by creating new, valuable content that positions them as the recognized expert everyone talks about and recommends.

What we did: This is where extensive local keyword research became crucial. We analyzed exactly what questions potential customers were asking online and what topics competitors weren't covering well. Then we created comprehensive content around those opportunities—detailed guides about different treatments, educational articles about beauty concerns, and authoritative content that demonstrated 614 Beauty's expertise.

We built what's called "pillar content"—comprehensive pieces on core topics that become the foundation for smaller, related articles. Think of it like creating the definitive guide to skincare, then supporting it with specific articles about different skin types, seasonal concerns, and treatment options.

We also enhanced existing content with better photos, clearer descriptions, and more helpful information, but the focus was on strategic content creation based on thorough research of what customers were actually searching for.

Why this creates lasting results: Unlike paid ads that stops working the moment you stop paying, this strategic content continues attracting customers month after month. Each piece builds on the others, creating what we call "compound growth"—like interest in a savings account, the results keep growing even when you're not actively working on them. Regular updates and fresh content keep 614 Beauty ahead of competitors who might try to copy their success. It's much easier to maintain a leadership position than to fight for it from behind.

Conclusion

614 Beauty's transformation demonstrates why sequence matters in digital marketing. We took a website that was actively losing potential customers and turned it into a customer-generating machine in nine months. These results were so clear and measurable that they naturally became a local SEO case study in what the right steps can achieve.

The key insight: most businesses try to do everything at once and get mediocre results. We focused on the biggest problems first, then built momentum systematically. Fix the foundation, optimize for search, then establish market authority. Each phase sets up the next for maximum impact.

This isn't just about getting more website visits—it's about building a digital presence that consistently brings in qualified customers who are actively looking for your services. That's the difference between marketing that costs money and marketing that makes money.

Interesting to learn more about process? Check our our local SEO Services, or simply reach out to us to start your SEO journey today.

The Sparqflow team in a customer meeting discussing web design and SEO results
About Sparqflow
Sparqflow is a Columbus, Ohio-based web design and SEO agency that empowers startup founders, entrepreneurs, and managers to accelerate growth.
We help you craft stunning websites that capture your brand's essence, boost search rankings, and convert visitors into loyal customers.
Share this article
Facebook icon to share this blog post on Facebook.LinkedIn icon to share this blog post on LinkedIn.X icon to share this blog post on X.Icon to copy the URL link for sharing.